Wednesday, November 28, 2012

Domestic Violence and the Bharatiya Nari



 A woman patient was referred this morning from the casualty/emergency department for pain on the face and jaws. Before speaking to the patient it is customary to read up on the name, age and other details from the case notes written by the emergency doctor who had checked her in. There was a small red marking on her case notes, in the top left corner, a question mark with the words “MLC” written beside it. Which meant in doc-speak – “Be Alert” possible medico-legal case, with all the attendant complications to follow. And no wonder the others had deftly passed on this patient to me to deal with. A medico-legal case for your information involves any injury to a patient obtained through violence and the doctor attending should be ready to go to a court and give evidence of the actual injuries and sufferings of the patient. As we are all aware, this evidence business is not a one-time only thing in Indian courts, every time the case gets called to the court but also gets postponed the doctor has to be at the court again and again, neglecting all his other work. Now for a dozen medico-legal patients, think about how much time the doctor has to spend in court every month. Hence most doctors try to avoid getting involved in such patients.



Anyway this patient had ended up in front of me and I had to get on with it. So as I examined her and asked her what happened she told me the pain in the cheeks and jaws, especially around her jaw joint (the tempro-mandibular joint which connects the lower jaw to the upper jaw in front of the ears) was there ever since her husband had slapped her last night. And there I had my cue. So I asked her, if she was planning to give a police complaint against her husband for hitting her, under the domestic violence act. She shook her head and said vehemently and with noticeable pride that she had no intention of blaming her husband for anything and there was no chance of getting the police involved in what was now amicably settled between them. But it was my duty to have asked for the clarification and I had done my duty.

So having got that statement from her, I went on to examine her and found that she had no fracture of the jaw bones or joint but on the contrary her ear drum had burst on that side. When I mentioned this fact to her she said so proudly (and with a laugh) that her husband was so strong he had burst her ear with just one blow. So then I asked her why? Why he had struck her? Was it a regular thing? For this time she had been lucky, there was no major damage to her but the next time she could even end up dead if struck with such force in the wrong area of the face or head. But she didn’t answer my questions then, so I went on to order investigations and talk about treatment options. And finally when she was leaving with the prescription she volunteered the information that she was already taking medicines for infertility and she wanted to know if any of these medicines will interfere with those other drugs. When I asked her how long she was being treated for infertility she said five years and that’s the reason this quarrel happened. Her husband had said something about her not having a child all these years and she had retorted that the fault might not be on her side and she if he really wanted a child that bad, she would go sleep with someone, get pregnant and give her husband that child. And that’s when he had slapped her. After saying this, she took her prescription and left.



Later, when I was in the canteen and had some free time to think over the day’s events, I pondered over this strange drama. Why was that woman so proud of him, of his strength and of his violent behavior? Do some women get their kicks from being punched and thrown around? Is that at all possible? Or was she acting before me?  The woman had looked educated and was probably financially independent and could support herself without her husband. But she still hung on to him despite getting blows for her patience. This was contrary to all the media reports we read about educated and financially independent women not being victims of domestic violence and only the sole wage earning lower classes getting away with this sort of behavior. And she didn’t even have kids to worry about spoiling their future due to any action she took on her husband.

And as she said the infertility could be due to any number of causes on both sides. And none of which reasons excused the husband from hitting her violently. But she was actually proud of him in front of me, defending his right to hit her, refusing to give a police complaint, even thought the risk of a bigger injury in the near future was threatening. Did she love him that much? Or what was she thinking? I am merely a writer of medicines and I don’t have the answers to these complicated questions. Hell I don’t even have the answers to some of my own questions about what goes on in a woman’s mind (considering my distinct lack of success so far with the fairer sex). So I offer no expert analysis here. But maybe you my readers can help me with understanding this Bharatiya Nari's devotion to her abusive husband and why she keeps on clinging to him despite the risk to her life. I hope at least the female readers of my blog can explain the why to me. Do enlighten me....

13 comments:

  1. "Asli bharathiya nari" word i Often use to refer these kinda women ;)
    1. May be her marriage was love marriage and she could never hate or leave him and that's why she has got stucked up with the marriage
    2.She may appear to be financially independent, but may in reality doesn't have any backing/parental support to live independently. So she stays clinged.

    whatever it is defending his right to slap her is stupidity at its worst form...Poor lady!I'm short of words

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. will love permit continuous physical abuse? i think she was stupid too..but it was not my place to say it...i mean my duty was over in treating her, i had no right to interfere in her private life..so all i could do was wonder

      Delete
  2. Yes GP, absolutely.Don't we hear/read about things on similar lines in TV /newspapers. You will be knowing about stockholm syndrome. This case is also something IIIr to that.These kinda people have an affection n love even towards their perpetrator.

    -they are used to it n might have seen their mom getting hit by her dad and grown up that way.So perceive it as normal phenomena.
    - They have no other option, life outside is more horrible.
    - Too cultural/religious, so they might not believe in divorce.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So anything is acceptable? even the risk to their lives? in stockholm syndrome the victim has no option.here the woman was quite clear headed. but anyway, i dont know the full story. maybe she had her reasons and i am misjudging her... hope i dont see her again with something like this

      Delete
  3. The concept of educated and financially independent woman vulnerable is not a myth.From what I have seen, to get rid of domestic violence you don't have to be educated,for financially independent or support group.All a woman needs is courage but it is not very easy because women lose hopes once succumbed to domestic violence.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i wish that every woman has some kind of support system, maybe a parent, or a sibling or a friend or a colleague who will help give her the push when it comes to standing up for herself. the idea that we are not alone is what often helps us unlock the hidden courage inside ourselves. and to accept such behaviour and to live with the abuser after losing hope is one of the biggest tragedies of life

      Delete
  4. Yes GP, as Chitta Vritti said its a Stockholm Syndrome. Mine s a love marriage and often i gulp down abuses thrown at me, just for the sake of my 'mute' husband! They wont recognise our talents, skills and provide a shot in the arm! Just because u r not from their own bloody community! F*$%... And my husband would say i'm jealous of his sister, i dont cook like his great granny and all dat. And once wen he came 2 me in the bed, I asked him after love-making: Did i giv u d same satisfaction as ur granny/sister gave you?! Phat, I got a slap and i slapped him back also :). Now 4 years down d line, those comparisions are gone but still we are inferior to the ladies in his household!! No matter jhowmuch ever u juggle between home and work, invest his mpney wisely, bla bla....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. wow!! Anon..whoever you are i am awestruck at your honest comment. you are a very brave lady to go through things like this for four years and still satay with him... nowadays i see so many girls ending their marriages within a few month's for the flimsiest of reasons citing incompatibility, but you have really worked hard at your marriage with full commitment. i hope and pray that things get better for you and you get recognized not only for your talent and skills but also for your understanding and patience. your husband sure is a lucky man. tell him that from me. cheers

      Delete
  5. I think the answer goes much deeper. She might have been brought up to respect a "real man" the definition of whom is a brute. Even educated and financially well off women suffer in silence as victims of domestic violence in a world where family honour matters more than individual rights, in a society where marriage as an institution must be protected, in a social order which involves the women in subjugating themselves willingly for a cause that she is institutionalised/brainwashed into believing is more important than her own physical and mental well-being: the (male) heir.
    This woman perhaps shared her husband's value system: that the inability to produce an heir was an offence. Being morally uprighteous, she felt she deserved the treatment meted out to her. But being educated and knowing that infertility was a problem that both sexes could be blighted with, she happened to lash out against him.

    The interesting thing to think of is, would her husband have gone to get an infertility test done? Also, would she still be as proud of him were he to prove to be impotent: na-mard, as they say in hindi? Or is her admiration for his manliness limited to his brute strength and abuse of her person?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. thank you for that incisive analysis beeej..you have given me several points to ponder. yes, a sense of guilt at her inability to provide an offspring might prompt her to excuse his behavior towards her. the point that the instuition of marrigae must be protected at all cost constantly dinned since childhood (plus the real costs involved in getting a divorce) into women makes them passively accept things to a level which will not be tolerated in any other sphere- at work for instance. if i see her again- which i hope not- maybe i will try to ask/understand her point of view too..

      Delete
  6. I think you should have referred her to a psychiatrist. She was suffering from masochism, a form of self destructive psycological disorder. What she needs is counselling and behavioural therapy.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The other alternative is that she comes from a wwf family where violence is normalized and an accepted part of social behaviour

    ReplyDelete