History is a funny thing. It keeps getting revised every time
someone feels uncomfortable with the version they have been taught. A perfect
example of revisionist history would be how within the twenty year span of my
education (yep, I did study that long taking into account school, college,
college, college and.. you get the idea) M K Gandhi has gone from Mahatma to
villain in the popular discourse or should I say in online discourse. The general
public, the ones who don’t have always-on internet at their finger tips don’t much
seem to care for this Gandhi bashing, excepting a few dyed in the wool revisionist
historians. But online? That’s a different story.
Gandhi has been accused of everything- from favoring minorities
(by the hindutva group), to favoring the majority community (by extremist
minority parties), to being a closet communist (by the progressive business
barons or robber barons in the old west parlance), to being a closet capitalist
( by the still unreformed dregs of communism persisting), to being a sexual
deviant (by those with perverted fantasies), to having hogged all the fame of
the freedom movement (by bong devotees of netaji), of being an radical at heart
(by the nehruvian crowd), to being a pacifist to the core (by the bhagat singh
worshippers), of being an anti-dalit (by the ambedkarites), to being a pro-dalit
(by the orthodox Brahmins). History, properly read suggest that Gandhi might
have been all this, but also indisputably he was a cut above the rest of the
freedom fighting crowd.
Without that man Gandhi, being thrown out of that South African
train, the course of modern Indian history would have been so very different. The
constitutional methods of the then Congress party and the acts of extremism by
the radicals group would have together achieved precisely- Zero. We would all
still be saluting the Union Jack and admiring Kate Middleton and Prince Harry
instead of our very own princelings –Priyanka Vadera and Rahul Gandhi. A fact
which will not be admitted publicly by the Nehruvites, the Ambedkarites, the Sardar
Patelites, the Jinnahites, the Netaji Bose’ites and all those ites try to pull
down that towering figure Gandhi for the precise reason that gunslingers in the
old westerns used to challenge the biggest man in town to a gunfight- to make a
name for themselves by beating the heavyweight in the room.
Without that old man from a small town in Gujarat, Nehru would
have had no country to rule and leave to his offspring, ambedkar would have had
no chance to even think, leave alone get the opportunity to draft as important
an article as the constitution, sardar patel would have had no chance to show
his steel frame in uniting the country, and I could go on and on. Gandhi alone
gave them that chance, the chance to show their caliber. He gave them that
chance by refusing to take injustice anymore and standing up for himself and
the people of his country. Not for the hindus, not for the muslims, not for the
dalits, not for the bengalis, not for the landed gentry. FOR EVERYONE. If that doesn’t
make him a great man, I don’t know what will.
To conclude with Einsteins eulogy “Generations to come will
scarce believe that such a man once walked among us”. And Gandhi, if he were
alive today, would be the first person to enjoy the jokes at his expense, plus
he would have been very active on facebook/twitter and all, offering his views
there, unlike the current bunch of leaders we are saddled with. So don’t knock
what you don’t understand.
Yeah, there is no point in blaming him and hating him... he was at times irrational, but he was never spiteful or deceitful. He was obstinate in his outdated opinions, but he had a good heart... and that's rare these days.
ReplyDeleteprecisely Karen....i am not saying he was through and through a saint but he was a human being. now how many of our current leaders (those who criticise him?) you can say that of?
DeleteHistory is subjective Ashwini...the ones who win write their own history...i wont even be surprised if in the future the name gandhi starts with Indira gandhi and MK Gandhi gets completely erased from history books. The greatest compliment we can give MK Gandhi was, despite his flaws and all, he was a human being, not a beast who goes around looting the country. proof of that is how he left his children penniless after his death. so those who criticise him had better re-think their own legacies before doing so.
ReplyDelete